Boiled Custard Vs Eggnog

Boiled Custard vs Eggnog: Which Is Better?

The holiday season is a time of year when families and friends come together to celebrate with festive foods and drinks. One of the most popular treats during this time is creamy, rich, and flavorful eggnog, a traditional drink enjoyed by many. However, there is another drink that is just as popular but often overlooked, boiled custard. Both of these drinks are creamy, sweet, and indulgent, and are often considered a Christmas classic. But, what is the difference between the two, and which one is better? In this article, we will do a deep dive into boiled custard vs eggnog, compare them both, and help you decide which is the perfect drink for your holiday festivities.

Boiled Custard

Boiled custard is an old-fashioned drink that has been around for centuries. It is made by heating milk, sugar, and egg yolks on the stove until it thickens into a creamy custard. This drink is served warm and can be spiked with your choice of liquor, such as bourbon, rum, or brandy, to create an alcoholic version.

The texture of boiled custard is velvety and smooth, and it has a rich and creamy flavor that is sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. The drink is often topped with a sprinkle of nutmeg or cinnamon for added flavor, and it is not uncommon to see it served in a punch bowl for family gatherings.


Eggnog is a creamy drink that is also made with milk, sugar, and eggs, but it has a few extra ingredients that give it a distinct flavor. Evaporated or condensed milk, heavy cream, and vanilla extract are added to the mixture to make it rich and silky. The drink can be served chilled or warm and is also spiked with liquor, such as brandy, rum, or whiskey, to give it an extra kick.

Eggnog has a slightly thicker consistency than boiled custard and is often frothy due to the addition of whipped cream. The flavor of eggnog is sweet and nutty, with a hint of spice from cinnamon or nutmeg. It is also common to see eggnog served in eggnog glasses, which are tall, slim glasses that showcase the creamy layers of the drink.

Boiled Custard vs Eggnog: The Comparison

Now that we understand what boiled custard and eggnog are let us take a closer look at them side-by-side to see how they differ in taste, texture, and preparation.


Boiled custard and eggnog both have a sweet, creamy flavor, but their overall taste is different. Boiled custard has a richer, eggy taste, while eggnog has a nuttier, spicier flavor. Eggnog also has a sweeter taste than boiled custard due to the addition of whipped cream and condensed milk.


The texture of boiled custard is smoother and creamier than eggnog, which is thicker and often frothy. Boiled custard is served warm, while eggnog can either be served warm or chilled, depending on your preference.


Boiled custard and eggnog share many of the same ingredients, such as milk, sugar, and eggs, but eggnog has a few extra ingredients, such as heavy cream and vanilla extract. The addition of these ingredients gives eggnog a more complex flavor and a thicker, creamier texture.


Boiled custard and eggnog are both relatively easy to make, but boiled custard takes longer to prepare due to the slower cooking process. Eggnog can be whipped up quickly and easily, making it a popular choice for impromptu get-togethers.

Alcoholic Variations

Both boiled custard and eggnog can be spiked with your favorite liquor to create a boozy version of the drink. Popular additions include brandy, rum, or whiskey. Eggnog is often paired with spiced rum or bourbon, while boiled custard is commonly paired with brandy or whiskey.

Boiled Custard Vs Eggnog: Which Is Better?

Deciding which drink is better is entirely subjective and depends on your personal preferences. If you prefer a sweeter, nuttier taste and a thicker texture, eggnog is the way to go. If you like a richer, creamier taste and a smoother texture, boiled custard is the perfect choice.


Which is healthier, boiled custard or eggnog?

Neither are particularly healthy options. Both are high in calories, sugar, and saturated fat due to the use of milk, cream, and eggs. If you are looking for a healthier alternative, consider using low-fat milk and reducing the amount of added sugar.

Can I make boiled custard or eggnog without eggs?

It is possible to make both drinks without eggs. You can substitute the eggs in boiled custard with cornstarch or custard powder, and in eggnog with tapioca flour or custard powder.

Can I use a milk substitute in boiled custard or eggnog?

Yes, you can use a milk substitute, such as almond or coconut milk, in both drinks. Keep in mind that the substitution will alter the taste and texture of the drink.

Can boiled custard or eggnog be made ahead of time?

Yes, both drinks can be made ahead of time and stored in the refrigerator for up to three days. To serve, heat up the boiled custard or allow the eggnog to come to room temperature before serving.


Boiled custard and eggnog are two classic holiday drinks that everyone should try at least once. Both drinks are indulgent, creamy, and flavorful, and are the perfect treat for the holiday season. Whether you prefer the nutty sweetness of eggnog or the richer, creamier taste of boiled custard, both drinks are sure to satisfy your taste buds. With this detailed comparison between the two drinks, you can now choose the perfect drink for your holiday celebration.